Oregon's Court of Appeals ruled inTrapp v.
Hodgesthat a plaintiff was entitled to seek
attorneys' fees after trial because two commas made a
settlement offer ambiguous.
Background
The case concerned a minor motor vehicle accident. Before suit was
filed, the claimant demanded $10,000, plus reimbursement of his PIP
benefits. The defendant's carrier responded to the $10,000
demand with this offer: "We've evaluated your client's
claim based on the information presented and are prepared to
resolve their injury claim for $3,900 (Three Thousand Nine Hundred
Dollars), inclusive of all liens, plus PIP owed to State
Farm." State Farm's PIP lien was $2,684.36.
The plaintiff filed suit and was awarded $2,500 after a jury
trial. The plaintiff then sought $31,960 in attorneys' fees. He
relied on ORS 20.080, a statute that allows a plaintiff to recover
attorneys' fees if the plaintiff (1) prevails in a tort case;
(2) is seeking $10,000 or less; (3) made a pre-suit demand