In Ramirez v. Trans Union, the Ninth Circuit addressed
whether, at the class certification stage of a putative class case,
only the named plaintiff or all class members must have Article III
standing (i.e., a concrete injury in fact) to certify a
class.1 The Ninth Circuit has been, and arguably
remains, divided on this issue. However, the court may have more or
less settled the issue (at least for now) by ruling that only the
named plaintiff must have standing. Importantly, the court also
observed that all class members must have standing at the
damages stage of a certified class
action. Thus, although the plaintiff's bar is likely to view
the opinion as a resounding victory, the issue of standing in fact
will remain a lively one in any damages class action certified
under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23.