New York Partner
James T. Whalen, Jr. and his trial team—Partners
Jennifer Oxman,
Nick Hurzeler, and
David Rosenthal—recently obtained a
defense verdict on behalf of a volunteer firefighter struck by a
car accident, resulting in a partial leg amputation.
The New York office represented a volunteer firefighter who was
accused of illegally parking his truck on a public sidewalk and
obstructing the view of both the plaintiff and the driver of the
vehicle, which the plaintiff said substantially contributed to an
accident in which he was hit by an oncoming car.
The plaintiff attempted to show through the use of an accident
reconstructionist and the analysis of surveillance video that the
volunteer firefighter's vehicle was fully on the sidewalk in
violation of Vehicle and Traffic Law Section 1202, which was
negligence "per se." Plaintiff also produced a
firefighting expert who testified that as a fire lieutenant, the
defendant had a superior duty to protect his