New York, N.Y. (May 3, 2024) - New York
Partners Adam Schwartzstein, James Strauss, and Jennifer Harris
recently secured a dismissal of a personal injury plaintiff's
complaint on summary judgment, with a New York federal judge
agreeing with their argument that the plaintiff had not suffered a
"serious injury" as defined by New York Insurance Law
§5102(d).
In an extensive 27-page decision, Hon. Rachel Kovner of the U.S.
District Court for the Eastern District of New York held that
despite the plaintiff having had years of medical treatment along
with a surgery to his left shoulder, he nevertheless failed to meet
the standards of a "serious injury" given the manner of
his doctors' range of motion testing, his doctors' failure
to prove that the plaintiff's injuries were causally related to
the accident, the plaintiff's quick return to work, and the
defendants' biomechanical expert report that the
plaintiff's injuries could not have been caused by the accident
at