In 2018, our blogpost on In re Johnson & Johnson
Talcum Powder Products Marketing, Sales Practices & Liability
Litigation, 903 F.3d 278 (3d Cir. 2018), was entitled
"Money For Nothing? No Standing This Time in the Third
Circuit." There, it appeared that the Third Circuit had drawn
an eminently reasonable bright line disallowing no-injury class
actions by plaintiffs who used a product without incident, and then
belatedly claimed that the product had some attribute that it
supposedly should not have had. J&J Talc held –
"succinctly" – that "buyer's remorse,
without more, is not a cognizable injury" that provides
constitutional standing in federal court. Id. at 281.
What a difference six years – and a different panel
– make. Recently, in Huertas v. Bayer US LLC, ___
F.4th ___, 2024 WL 4703136 (3d Cir. Nov. 7, 2024), the same court
rejected a standing argument on essentially identical facts. The
unsuccessful plaintiff class in J&J Talc alleged that
the product at