Companies facing ongoing or threatened litigation must sometimes
estimate their likely or possible financial exposure — for
internal purposes, reporting to auditors or other reasons.
Depending on the circumstances, one would think that such figures
so clearly reflect a lawyer's judgment that they deserve work
product protection.
In CourtAlert.com, Inc. v. American LegalNet, Inc., No.
20-CV-07739 (VSB) (VF), 2024 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 206259 (S.D.N.Y. Nov.
12, 2024), plaintiff sought merger agreement documents between
defendant and another company. The court ordered them produced, but
upon defendant's request reviewed them in camera to
determine if defendant's reserve amount for the litigation
described in the merger documents deserved work product protection.
The court agreed that the amount could be redacted, understandably
recognizing that courts "have permitted redactions of
individual reserve figures, concluding that such information is
protected work product