Today's guest post is from Wendy
Lumish and Daniel
Rock of Bowman &
Brooke. We sought them out because they wrote a
successful amicus curiae brief in the case they
discuss. That case is a major win for all Florida defendants,
bringing Florida summary judgment practice into the Twenty-First
Century. As always our guest posters are 100% responsible for
what they write, deserving all the credit (and any blame).
**********
This guest post is pleased to report on a change in Florida law
that replaces a nearly insurmountable fifty-year-old summary
judgment standard.
Based on a 1966 decision from the Florida Supreme Court, a party
moving for summary judgment in Florida for decades had the burden
of “conclusively” disproving the non-moving
party's theory of the case. See Holl v.
Talcott, 191 So. 2d 40, 45-47 (Fla. 1966). Under this
standard, even speculative evidence was sufficient to defeat
motions for summary judgment.