There were two recent cases from the 7th Circuit
Court of Appeals, one on May 16 and one on May 17. The parties,
judges, and areas of law were different. But the underlying
question in both cases was the same. When does someone give up a
right to something to which they would be otherwise entitled? In
that regard, they present interesting contrasts. In one case, the
court concluded the claimant did not give up its right (at least at
the pleading stage). But in the other, the claimant lost.
Waiver of Right to Trademark
Hyson USA, Inc. is a food-distribution company owned by Leonid
Tansky. One of its managers was Karolis Kaminskas. In early 2012,
Hyson USA had financial problems and could no longer afford its
liability insurance. As a result, it ceased business. In September,
2012, Kaminskas formed his own company, Hyson 2U, Ltd. and hired
Tansky. Hyson USA transferred its branded inventory and equipment
to Hyson 2U. Hyson 2U even leased the warehouse from which