Like a Sergio Leone scene, the Sixth Circuit issued an
explosive en banc denial of CIC Services LLC v. Internal Revenue
Service (a case we covered back in June).
As he did at the panel stage, Judge Clay defended the
application of the Anti-Injunction Act, which here bars CIC
Services from challenging the IRS's categorization of an
in-house insurance company as a tax shelter. He minced no words,
characterizing Judge Thapar's en banc "dissental"
(itself a defense of Judge Nalbandian's earlier panel dissent)
as an attempt "to inflict death by distorted originalism on
the modern administrative state." According to Judge Clay, the
case was "about statutory interpretation, not about the
constitutionality of the so-called administrative state, or even
the constitutionality of the AIA."