Key Issue
Whether the district court erred in certifying an injunction
class under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(b)(2) where the
putative class sought retrospective relief and the proposed class
may be both under- and over-inclusive.
Background
The appeal in AA Suncoast Chiropractic Clinic v. Progressive
American Insurance Co. arises from a dispute concerning
Florida's provisions governing the amount of insurance coverage
available to motorists in automobile accidents, and when that
coverage may be limited.29 Under Florida law, car
insurance policies must provide personal injury benefits up to
$10,000, but only injured motorists who have an "emergency
medical condition" ("EMC") are eligible to receive
the full $10,000. For non-EMC accidents, coverage is capped at
$2,500.30 Florida law also governs who decides whether
an accident involves an EMC (an "EMC Determination").