On June 18, 2019, in Marchand v. Barnhill, the Delaware
Supreme Court, in an opinion written by Chief Justice Leo E.
Strine, Jr. on behalf of a unanimous court, issued a decision
reversing the Court of Chancery's dismissal of a stockholder
derivative suit alleging Caremark claims1 — that the board
failed to provide adequate oversight of a key risk area and thus
breached its duty of loyalty. The case arose out of a listeria
outbreak in ice cream made by Blue Bell Creameries USA Inc. that
sickened many consumers, caused three deaths and resulted in a
total product recall.
Key Determinations
The key Delaware Supreme Court determinations, both fact-driven,
were:
- Independence. The
Supreme Court held that one director, viewed by the Court of
Chancery as independent, was not independent based on the
allegations in the complaint. As a result, the court found that a
majority of the board was not independent and disinterested for
purposes of the board's consideration