It is well-recognized that often, when an attorney sues a
client for unpaid fees, the client will bring a counterclaim for
legal malpractice. Some sources indicate that the likelihood of
receiving such a counterclaim could be as high as 40 percent;
others place it even higher.
Although many state bars recognize that attorney-client disputes
may be resolved through arbitration, the use of mandatory
arbitration clauses in engagement letters may be subject to federal
law. The FAA (Federal Arbitration Act) governs requests for
arbitration and, on its face, is supreme to state law on the
issue.
Recently, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit
reviewed the application of the FAA to a mandatory arbitration
clause in an attorney engagement letter. Smith v.
Lindemann, No. 16-3357 (3d Cir. 2017). In a nonprecedential
opinion, the court concluded that, although a mandatory arbitration
clause could be set aside on the basis of fraud, duress or
unconscionability