Last week, we found ourselves focusing on spoliation issues in
two different cases, one at the front-end (an early case
assessment) and one at the back-end (haggling over jury
instructions). The Actos spoliation saga has made any
sentient defendant antsy about these things. Thus, it is worthwhile
to discuss Moore v. Abiomed, Inc., 20 U.S. Dist. LEXIS
147191 (C.D. Illinois Aug. 29, 2019), for its potentially helpful
spoliation ruling, even if the rest of the opinion is
forgettable.
The plaintiff had undergone open heart surgery, and the pump
used during that surgery malfunctioned. The pump could not be
removed at the end of the surgery, though it was designed to
release and thereby facilitate such removal. Instead, a follow-up
surgery was required for removal. The plaintiff alleged that the
failed initial removal of the pump caused him to suffer from
ischemia in extremities, resulting in the loss of three fingers in
his dominant hand. The plaintiff filed claims