Amongst the many decisions an attorney makes throughout
litigation, there is one choice that can shape the outcome of a
case way before filing a motion, setting discovery and trial
strategy, or even calling a witness: venue, where the case will be
adjudicated. The governing statute limits patent venue to (i) the
judicial district in which the defendant resides; or (ii) where the
defendant has "committed acts of infringement and has a
regular and established place of business." 28
U.S.C. §1400(b). If this sounds narrower than the
"traditional" venue rules, that's because it is.
Initially, the Supreme Court interpreted Section 1400(b) to be
"a restrictive measure, limiting a prior, broader venue."
Stonite Prods. Co. v. Melvin Lloyd Co., 315
U.S. 561, 563(1942).
That said, plaintiffs are permitted to engage in "a certain
amount of forum shopping" via
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 41(a)(1). In re TikTok,
Inc., 85
F.4th 352 (5th Cir. 2023) (recognizing Rule 41(a)(1)