Is imitation the sincerest form of flattery? Not according to
brand owner Jack Daniel's Properties, Inc., ("JDPI"),
which owns the JACK DANIEL'S source identifiers for alcoholic
beverages and other goods - most notably, whiskey.
For the better part of a decade, JDPI has been embroiled in a
dispute with toy maker VIP Products LLC, ("VIP"), which
makes humorous chew toys that allegedly parody well-known products.
The toy shown below is at the center of this dispute, and features
elements of authentic Jack Daniel's® whiskey bottles and
labeling, and dog-related puns, such as "BAD SPANIEL,"
"OLD No. 2," and "TENNESSEE CARPET":

In 2014, JDPI accused VIP of trademark infringement and demanded
that VIP cease all sales of the BAD SPANIELS chew toy. VIP then
sued for a declaratory judgment, including a declaration of
non-infringement. JDPI counterclaimed for infringement and related
causes of action, including dilution of a famous trademark. The
U.S. District Court