On November 19, 2018, the Supreme Court of the United States
(SCOTUS) rejected a petition to review
the PTAB's refusal to deny IPR institution under § 325(d),
in a case where the challenged patent had survived several previous
validity challenges that relied on the same prior art used in the
IPR.
The petition was filed by SSL Services, LLC ("SSL"),
owner of U.S. Patent No. 6,158,011 (the "'011
Patent"). The '011 patent relates to a system for
establishing Virtual Private Networks, which allow secure
communication between computers over the Internet. The '011
patent was previously the target of three reexamination requests
based on, inter alia, two prior art references: Alden and
Takahashi. The PTO granted the first request but found that the
Alden and Takahashi references did not invalidate the '011
Patent. The PTO declined the second reexamination request because
it had already considered the Alden and Takahashi references in the
first reexamination. The PTO also