In Power Integrations v.
Semiconductor Components, the Federal Circuit ruled that
privy and real-party-in-interest (RPI) relationships arising after
a petition is filed but before institution may bar institution
under section 315(b). In that decision, the Federal Circuit also
upheld an exception to issue preclusion arising from another
inter partes review (IPR).
In March 2016, Semiconductor Components Industries, LLC, doing
business as ON Semiconductor ("ON") petitioned for IPR of
a patent owned by Power Integrations, Inc. ("PI"). PI had
previously asserted that patent in an infringement suit against
Fairchild and served the complaint on Fairchild a few years before
ON filed the IPR petition. In September 2016, after ON filed its
petition but before the Board decided whether to institute, ON
completed a merger with Fairchild. A few days later, the Board
instituted review and, after trial, cancelled the challenged
claims. PI appealed from the Board's final