In a precedential decision in HVLPO2, LLC v. Oxygen Frog, LLC,
the Federal Circuit held that non-expert testimony on obviousness
is inadmissible, further finding that the district court abused its
discretion by allowing a lay witness to testify on issues of patent
validity and by denying patent holder’s motion requesting a
new trial.
HVLPO2, LLC (HVO) sued Oxygen Frog for infringement of U.S.
Patent Nos. 8,876,941 and 9,372,488, directed to methods and
devices for controlling an oxygen-generating system used to manage
airflow for torch glass artists. The district court granted summary
judgement to HVO and the case proceeded to a jury trial on Oxygen
Frog’s assertions that the claims were obvious over two prior
art references. At trial, Oxygen Frog introduced deposition
testimony of a glass blowing artist whose online video was offered
as prior art. The witness had not been qualified as an expert
witness, and while proffered as a fact witness, he opined that it
would