Last week the Federal Circuit held that, like patent decisions,
ITC decisions pertaining to trademark infringement and validity are
not entitled to preclusive effect. Swagway v ITC, No.
2018-1672 (May 9, 2019). The Court reached its conclusion because
it saw "no reason to differentiate between the effect of the
Commission's patent-based decisions and the Commission's
decisions regarding trademarks."
In 2016, Segway filed a Complaint at the ITC alleging patent and
trademark infringement by several respondents, including Swagway.
During the investigation, and in an effort to avoid a potentially
preclusive decision from the ITC, Swagway moved for partial
termination of the investigation regarding the trademark
infringement allegations on the basis of a consent order
stipulation. The ITC did not specifically address Swagway's
motion but in the Initial Determination ("ID"), the ALJ
found Swagway's use of the SWAGWAY designation infringed
Segway's trademarks. Swagway