Fair use can be one of the most difficult issues that copyright
lawyers have to address due to decades of varying court rulings
applying the multi-factor balancing test, particularly in the face
of new technologies that use, modify, and aggregate data in ways
not envisioned under the Copyright Act. The Second Circuit's
February 2018 fair use decision in the dispute between Fox News
Network, LLC ("Fox") and TVEyes, Inc.
("TVEyes") added yet another wrinkle to fair use
jurisprudence when the court emphasized market effect over
transformative use, seemingly a departure from recent trends in the
application of the balancing test. (See Fox News Network, LLC v. TVEyes,
Inc., 883 F.3d 169 (2d Cir. 2018)). In recent weeks, the
Supreme Court denied TVEyes' petition for certiorari, leaving
in place the appeals court's decision; and Fox and TVEyes
settled the case, stipulating that TVEyes may no longer make
available, distribute, or publicly perform or display Fox's
copyrighted