The Delaware Superior Court, applying Delaware law, has held
that a group of D&O insurers' counterclaims and affirmative
defenses based on their policies' interrelated wrongful acts
provisions and pending and prior litigation exclusions could
proceed past the motion to dismiss stage. But the court also held
that the insurers' counterclaim and affirmative defense under
the policies' prior notice exclusions were inapplicable and
legally insufficient.
Nat'l Amusements, Inc. v. Endurance Am. Specialty Ins.
Co., 2023 WL 3145914 (Del. Super Ct. Apr. 28, 2023).
The insured sought coverage under its claims-made insurance
tower for an underlying litigation challenging the fairness of the
amount paid in a merger between two companies controlled by the
insured. The insurers denied coverage because the merger litigation
related back to four earlier litigations from 2016 challenging
several corporate governance decisions undertaken by the insured to
strengthen its control over