DVO, Inc. ("DVO") designs and builds anaerobic
digesters that use microorganisms to break down biodegradable
materials to create biogas. DVO designed and build a digester for
its customer, WTE-S&S AG Enterprise LLC ("WTE"). But
WTE was not happy and sued DVO for more than $2 million for breach
of contract, alleging that DVO failed to design the digester
properly.
DVO tendered the claim to Crum, its insurer. At first, Crum
defended DVO under a reservation of rights. But Crum changed its
mind and declined coverage and declined to defend the claim. Crum
cited the exclusion for claims or damages based upon or arising out
of breach of contract.
WTE filed for bankruptcy and pursued its claim against DVO in
the bankruptcy court. WTE won its claim against DVO and was awarded
$65,000 in damages and $198,000 in attorneys' fee. DVO turned
back to Crum, challenging its denial of coverage. Crum prevailed in
the district court, but not at the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals.
(Crum