Finding that the Stowers doctrine was not
“activated,” the United States District Court for the
Southern District of Texas entered summary judgment in favor of an
insurer on its declaratory relief claim. After an underlying
judgment was entered against its insured, the insurer sought
declaratory relief establishing that it owed only its remaining
policy limits for an excess verdict. The trial court agreed with
the insurer, entered summary judgment, and the matter is now on
appeal to the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth
Circuit.
The coverage dispute arose out of an underlying personal injury
suit filed in Texas state court. In the underlying suit, the
claimants sued the insured for injuries sustained while at the
insured's business. The claimants' counsel sent a
written settlement offer to the insured, requesting “payment
of all policy limits of any and all insurance contract,”
which was subsequently rejected. The claimants eventually prevailed
at trial