For several decades insurers and insureds alike agreed that a
construction defect case involved only a single occurrence.
Relatively recently, however, some insurers have reversed course
and began to argue that each such case involves several
occurrences. What precipitated this radical shift in approach? Did
insurers alter the fundamental terms of standard general liability
policies?
The change in approach can likely be traced to the proliferation
of high self- insured retentions ("SIR") in modern
general liability policies. Under these policies, an insured must
pay a substantial SIR for each occurrence before the insurer
provides any coverage.1 The number of SIRs involved in a
given case is therefore inversely correlated to the amount of
coverage the carrier must ultimately provide. The more occurrences
(and corresponding SIRs) at issue, the less the insurer will pay.
So, the per-occurrence SIR creates a perverse incentive for
insurers to argue that each case