The Situation On January 17, 2019, the Fifth
Circuit strongly suggested that claims for make-whole damages be
characterized as "unmatured interest" and that claims for
postpetition interest on unsecured debt be limited in bankruptcy
proceedings.
The Result The court's decision appears to
be one that favors debtors over lenders.
Looking Ahead It is unclear if the court's
reasoning will be adopted by other jurisdictions and/or in cases
with differing factual and legal grounds.
In Ultra Petroleum Corp., et al. v. Ad Hoc Committee of
Unsecured Creditors of Ultra Resources, Inc., et al. (In re Ultra
Petroleum Corp.),—F.3d—, No. 17-20793, 2019
WL 237365 (5th Cir. Jan. 17, 2019), the Fifth Circuit strongly
suggested that, regardless of the enforceability of make-whole and
default interest provisions under the relevant credit documents and
applicable state law: (i) claims for make-whole damages
triggered by a bankruptcy filing should be characterized as claims
for