When Alex's financial advisor
informed him that the portfolio manager (PM) of a high-performing
mutual fund in his portfolio was leaving, Alex became nervous. With
good reason: A quality PM can be influential in the overall success
of an investment plan.
Before giving up on the mutual
fund, Alex and his advisor discussed several aspects of how a PM
can affect a fund and whether the fund can continue to deliver
similar returns with a different PM.
A PM's Influence
First, Alex's advisor explained
that they will need to determine how important the PM was to the
fund. For example, when famed manager Peter Lynch stepped down from
the helm of Fidelity's Magellan Fund in May 1990, it was hard
to imagine anyone else duplicating Lynch's stock-picking
prowess, which produced an average annual return of almost 30%
during his 13-year tenure. That said, investors who remained with
Magellan saw it continue to outperform the market — albeit by
much smaller margins — under its