University of Houston Finance Professor Craig Pirrong analyzed a recent U.S. District Court for the
Southern District of New York determination that a Chicago trader and his
firm had neither manipulated nor attempted to manipulate the price
of certain interest rate swaps.
The CFTC alleged that the trader Donald R. Wilson and his firm
had "manipulat[ed] IDEX swap futures by entering large numbers
(well over 1000) of orders to buy the contract during the 15 minute
window used to determine the daily settlement price."
Professor Pirrong, who had initially commented on the case in September 2013, concluded that the CFTC
incorrectly believed that cleared futures and uncleared swaps are
equivalent, and that Mr. Wilson, therefore, should have entered
quotes equal to swap yields. Professor Pirrong stated that the
"advantage of being short the future should lead to a
difference between the futures yield and the swap yield."
According to Professor Pirrong, Mr. Wilson was correct