The uncertain and often lengthy time to get permitting decisions
is always near the top of the list of industry complaints. Section
165 of the Clean Air Act provides some relief by requiring certain
permit decisions to be made within one year. Last week, in Avenal Power Center v. EPA,
District Judge Richard Leon, in what may comfortably be described
as a strongly-worded opinion, held that EPA may not circumvent the
one-year limit on permit decisions by carving out from the one-year
period the time spent by the Environmental Appeals Board reviewing
EPA's permit decision.
In March 2008, Avenal Power filed an application for a PSD
permit necessary to construct a new gas-fired power plant in the
San Joaquin Valley in California. When EPA had not issued a
decision within two years, Avenal sued. In February 2011, Gina
McCarthy, head of EPA's air office, announced that EPA would
issue a permit decision by May 27, 2011. However, Judge Leon found
EPA's commitment to be