After more than ten years of protracted litigation brought by
the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), including
a stop at the U.S. Supreme Court, an Iowa federal district
court recently upheld an award of nearly $2 million in
attorneys' fees in favor of CRST Van Expedited. The court
criticized the EEOC's practice of presenting a moving target
while prosecuting a Title VII class action, holding that most of
the sexual harassment claims brought on behalf of nearly 78
claimants were "frivolous, groundless, or unreasonable."
What can employers learn from this decision?
How Did We Get Here?
In December 2005, a former CRST driver named Monika Starke filed
an EEOC charge of discrimination alleging that she was subjected to
sexual harassment. After making a reasonable cause determination
and failing to successfully conciliate Starke's matter, the
EEOC brought suit against CRST on behalf of Ms. Starke and a class
of other unnamed employees in an Iowa federal