All around the country, tipping practices have been coming under
scrutiny. Restaurants increasingly have abandoned their use
of tip credit — and tipping — partially due to a belief
that a higher wage not tied to the fluctuations of tipping is
better for morale and operations, and partially due to the
complexities of dealing with wage and hour compliance issues for
tipped employees. For those in the latter camp, however, the
Ninth Circuit, in
Oregon Rest. and Lodging Ass'n et al. v. Perez et
al., just decided that the Department of Labor
may regulate tip pooling even when the employer does not use the
FLSA's tip credit.
As we have
reported
previously, restaurant trade associations in Washington and
Oregon challenged the Department's 2011 final rule amending the
tip pool regulations. In promulgating those regulations, the
Department expressly rejected a prior Ninth Circuit case,
Cumbie v. Woody Woo, Inc., and stated that tips are the
property of the employee