In a short published opinion, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the
Ninth Circuit sided with the Third, Seventh and Tenth Circuits, and
split with the D.C. Circuit, over whether a federal district court
may award a "tax consequence adjustment" or "gross
up" for receipt of a back pay award given in one lump sum.
The relevant underlying facts of Clemens v.
CenturyLink1 are straightforward: a jury found that
the company had retaliated against the plaintiff and awarded him
approximately $157,000 in lost back pay and benefits under Title
VII. The plaintiff sought an adjustment to the award to account for
his paying more in taxes because the back pay was received as a
lump sum rather than having been earned over time. The district
court denied the request, citing "the lack of authorization
from the Ninth Circuit, the split among other Circuits on this
issue, and the parties' disagreement regarding an appropriate
methodology for calculating the tax consequences of a lump