A Florida court recently let a claim proceed under the Americans with
Disabilities Act ("ADA"), even though the employee had
been terminated for a positive drug test and the ADA has a specific
exclusion for current drug users. In legal terms, the court denied
the employer's initial motion to try and have the case
dismissed – so this is not a decision about whether the
employee's claim wins – but simply a decision concluding
that the former employee has presented a possible claim. However,
in more practical terms, the employer's actions may not have
passed the court's smell test.
Basing a termination on a positive drug test may feel like a
slam dunk in terms of legitimate reasons for a termination. So why
did it not work here to require immediate dismissal of the claim?
It is likely because of some alleged facts and some legal
ambiguity, but also probably because the employee's version of
the facts simply raised too many red flags.