When does evidence of malingering justify denial of a
long term disability claim? It depends. A
physician's subjective opinion regarding malingering may have
less weight than objective neuropsychological testing.
Key Take Away: When the
claimant's neuropsychological testing is rendered invalid due
to "failed validity tests," that may be enough to deny
the claim. It is important that the record contain
evidence how the tests were conducted, and how the tests
objectively measured validity.
Here's the case of Johnston v. Prudential Ins.
Co., 916 F. 3d 712 (8th Cir. February 25, 2019).
FACTS: Johnston, a computer engineer, sought
ERISA-governed long term disability benefits for cognitive
impairment after brain surgery. Johnston underwent
neuropsychological tests, rendered invalid because he "failed
almost all of the validity tests." Failed validity tests
indicate one may be "actively attempting to perform
poorly." After Prudential denied disability,