The DOL has waded into a long-simmering debate about whether
audio recordings of phone calls between a plan participant and the
plan's administrator or insurer should be provided to the
participant when challenging a benefit determination under the
plan, and they have come down squarely on the side of the
participant.
A recent DOL information letter lays out the Department's
view that audio recordings are considered relevant documents that
plan administrators, insurers, and third party administrators must
provide to a claimant upon request, regardless of how the recording
is used in the course of plan administration or a benefit
determination.
The DOL's position was expressed in response to a
claimant's request for an advisory opinion after a claims
administrator denied the claimant's request for audio
recordings of a phone call associated with an adverse
benefits determination. The DOL felt that this issue was best
addressed through an information letter (as