Under the US Criminal Code’s compassionate release provision, a court may reduce a criminal sentence after it is imposed if “extraordinary and compelling reasons warrant such a reduction.”1
On May 28, 2026, the Supreme Court of the United States issued two decisions — Rutherford v. United States2 and Fernandez v. United States3— holding that two specific sorts of considerations are categorically ineligible to satisfy that standard. In Rutherford, the Court held that compassionate release can never be based on the possible unfairness suffered by individuals sentenced under a statute Congress later makes more lenient via a non-retroactive amendment. And in Fernandez, the Court held that because Congress has provided for the possibility of habeas corpus for individuals who say they are innocent and were wrongly convicted, compassionate release is not a proper vehicle for claims of innocence.