Over the past two weeks, we've demonstrated that in criminal
cases as a whole, affirmances are pending substantially longer
between grant of review and oral argument than reversals are
– roughly 900 days more between 2000 and 2007, and more than
1000 days more between 2008 and 2016. So I wondered –
to what extent is the enormous margin explained by the very high
affirmance rate in death penalty cases? We recalculated the
criminal case statistics, dividing the data into non-death penalty
and death penalty cases.
Between grant of review and oral argument, affirmances were
pending longer for non-death penalty cases than reversals.
Affirmances took an average of 515.43 days from grant to argument,
while reversals were pending for 468.6 days. The data is
quite variable – the standard deviation for affirmances
between grant and oral argument is 300.68, and the standard
deviation for reversals is 235.35.