There are many good reasons to move to dismiss a consumer class
action. Costs and exposure tend to increase as the case proceeds
through discovery and the class certification stage. In some cases,
more experienced class action attorneys will associate in as lead
class counsel if a complaint survives the pleading stage. In the
consumer fraud class action context, the heightened pleading
standard applicable to fraud-based claims is another good reason to
bring a motion to dismiss. Unfortunately, defendants have had mixed
results on such motions.
The decision this week in Cortina v. Wal-Mart, USDC
S.D. Cal. Case No. 13-cv-2054 BAS (DHB), is a reminder that
defendants should continue to pursue motions to dismiss and press
plaintiffs to sufficiently articulate facts relating to all
elements, including those related to falsity and reasonable
consumer expectations. On June 23, 2014, Judge Cynthia Bashant, in
the Southern District of California, granted defendant's motion
to