Amid widespread concern about student debt and calls for higher
education institutions to put more "skin in the game,"
some have looked to income share agreements (ISAs) as part of the
solution. In general, under an ISA, a school or investor provides a
student funds for education today in exchange for a percentage of
the student's income tomorrow. Incentives are theoretically
aligned: the better job a student gets, the more money an
institution earns. Like other innovations, however, ISAs largely
exist in the interstices of existing legal frameworks and therefore
can present challenges.
A June 4 letter from Senator Elizabeth Warren and others
to the U.S. Department of Education (ED) and
to seven institutions that have implemented ISAs brings some of
those challenges to life. Senator Warren essentially characterizes
ISAs as no different than other forms of debt and worries that ISAs
"can be predatory and dangerous for students," can result
in violations of the Equal