Claims against insurers under Pennsylvania's Unfair Trade
Practices and Consumer Protection Law (UTPCPL) occupy a unique
place in its jurisprudence. Insurance is highly regulated, and many
other recovery avenues exist in Pennsylvania for aggrieved
insureds, such as breach of contract and bad faith. Usually,
insurance claims are tethered to contract law, since the
insured-insurer relationship and duties are governed by the
insurance policy. Courts should be reluctant to ignore contractual
principles when a UTPCPL claim arises out of a policy.
Generally, deceptive insurance solicitations are actionable
under the UTPCPL, while post-inception policy-related claims are
not. Toy v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Co.1
exemplifies this point. Toy involved an insurance
salesman's pre-issuance misrepresentations about the investment
qualities of a life insurance policy. The insured asserted both bad
faith and UTPCPL claims. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court affirmed
dismissal of the