In September 2021, the five-member Federal Trade Commission
voted 3-2 along party lines to withdraw its support for the
Vertical Merger Guidelines1 ("Guidelines") and
related FTC commentary on vertical merger enforcement.2
At the same time—indeed, only hours later on the same
day—the acting head of the Antitrust Division of the
Department of Justice issued a statement indicating that the
Guidelines "remain in place" at the DOJ while the agency
conducts a "careful review" of its process for making
enforcement decisions.3
What a difference a year makes. The Guidelines had been jointly
adopted by the FTC and the DOJ in mid-2020, marking the first
revision in more than 35 years and following the DOJ's failed
attempt to block AT&T's acquisition of Time
Warner.4 At that time, Republican leadership at both
agencies lauded the new Guidelines. The head of the DOJ's
Antitrust Division said the new Guidelines would "give greater
predictability and clarity to the business