Seeking to revive a criminal antitrust conviction, the DOJ last
week filed its reply brief in support of a petition for certiorari
asking the Supreme Court to hear its appeal of a Fourth Circuit
decision overturning a 2022 bid-rigging conviction. In the brief, the DOJ argued that the Fourth
Circuit erred when it ruled that only purely horizontal agreements
qualify as per se violations of the antitrust laws.
The defendant, Brent Brewbaker, was an executive of an aluminum
parts supplier, Contech. The government alleged that Brewbaker
submitted losing bids to the North Carolina Department of
Transportation in an effort to help a downstream customer of
Contech, Pomona Pipe Products, win the bid. Brewbaker was convicted
of bid-rigging, in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act, and
fraud. The Fourth Circuit upheld the fraud conviction but
overturned the Sherman Act one, ruling that because it was not
purely horizontal, the agreement between Contech and Pomona