In the recent decision of Matthew Rogerson (t/a
Cottesmore Hotel, Golf and Country Club) v Eco Top Heat & Power
Limited1, Mr Alexander Nissen QC (sitting as a
Judge of the High Court) provides yet more reasons to be cautious
when it comes to dealing with expert evidence. Katherine Butler
discusses the Court's reasoning when it comes to the
'price' to be paid by any party seeking to 'expert
shop' and, through which, how such practices are to be
discouraged.2
The Facts
In June 2018, there was a catastrophic fire at the Cottesmore
Hotel, Golf and Country Club (the Claimant), causing millions of
pounds worth of damage and business interruption losses. At the
time of the fire, Eco Top Heat (the Defendant), a contractor, was
carrying out works to install windows in a first floor area,
directly above a ground floor tunnel where the fire originated. The
Claimant alleged that the fire was started by a) an employee of the
Defendant discarding a cigarette or b) a loose spark