Case Alert - [2018] EWCA Civ 210
Court of Appeal rules that payment made after Part 36 offer
reduced the amount of the offer
In August 2015, the defendant made a Part 36 offer to pay the
claimant £15,000. The defendant subsequently paid the
claimant £10,000 and the issue in this case was whether that
payment reduced the Part 36 offer to £5,000 (and so the
claimant had beaten the offer at trial – if the Part 36 offer
was not reduced, the defendant would have beaten the offer). At
first instance, the judge held that the offer had been reduced and
the defendant appealed. The Court of Appeal has now dismissed that
appeal.
Reference was made to the earlier Court of Appeal decision of
Littlestone v Macleish, in which the Court of Appeal held
that a part payment made by the defendant following an admission of
liability had been made as part payment of the amount of the Part
36 offer and the payment and the offer should not be aggregated. In
reaching that