The recent decision in O'Grady v B15 Group
Limited [2022] EWHC 67 (QB) clarifies that the common law
doctrine of mistake is applicable to offers made under CPR Part 36.
Surprisingly, this issue had not been addressed directly by the
courts or the Rules Committee. In O'Grady,
Master Thornett held that nothing about Part 36 being a
self-contained code, or existing authority excluded the
applicability of mistake where obvious errors had been made.
The legal conundrum
The primary issue in O'Grady is the
question as to whether the common law principle of unilateral
mistake is consistent with CPR Part 36. The doctrine of
unilateral mistake arises where one party is mistaken and the other
party knows (or ought to have known) of the mistake. If the mistake
is fundamental to the contract, the contract can be voided.