Considering the allocation of risk is crucial when drafting
construction and project agreements. Often, insufficient attention
is paid to ensuring the prescribed insurance covers are appropriate
to the respective parties' risk exposures. When obtaining
joint-named insurance the consideration of the allocation of risk
as set out in the contracts' indemnities and liabilities
provisions is very important.
Historically, the courts have not allowed an insurer to pay out
to insured party A and then exercise subrogation rights in order to
recover from insured party B. At one time the basis of this rule
was "circuity" as it was thought that insured party B
would then be entitled to an indemnity under the insurance. In
Co-operative Retail Services Limited v. Taylor Young
Partnership Limited [2002] 1 WLR 1419 ("the CRS
Decision") the House of Lords stated (obiter) that the basis
of the 'rule' was found, not in the principle of circuity,
but in the underlying