In Attleys Roofing Limited v QBE UK Limited [2026] EWHC 2742 (Comm), the High Court held, in the context of a preliminary issues hearing, that a hot works condition in a public liability policy imposed an absolute obligation to comply with specified precautions, despite describing them as "reasonable precautions".
A conventional "reasonable precautions" clause is usually breached only where the insured has acted recklessly. Here, however, the wording made even a negligent or innocent failure to take the specified precautions a breach of a condition precedent to indemnity. The decision highlights the importance of reading "reasonable precautions" language in its particular policy context.
BACKGROUND