In the absence of express contractual provisions, an employer has discretion to confer benefits upon its employees. However, recent decisions in relation to the employer’s implied duty of mutual trust and confidence (including its obligation to act in good faith vis-à-vis its employees) have highlighted constraints on the way in which an employer is able to exercise such discretion. Two cases in particular highlight this trend. These cases and their implications are outlined below.
Clark v Nomura
In this case, the High Court held that an employer must not act irrationally or perversely in exercising its discretion in awarding a discretionary bonus.
Mr Clark was dismissed in 1997. Mr Clark’s contract of employment stated that he would be entitled to participate in a "discretionary bonus scheme, which is not guaranteed in any way, and is dependent upon individual performance …". In the previous financial year, Mr Clark had received a bonus of £2.55 million, having earned profits