Mediation has become an integral part of the civil litigation
process in the Gauteng division. The Mediation Protocol
("the Protocol") has elevated the
procedural significance of Rule 41A, and with it, the risks for
practitioners who do not engage with its requirements carefully.
Where a Rule 41A notice may once have been considered to be a
routine step, the Protocol's recent amplification has clarified
when, how and on what basis a party may oppose referral to
mediation without being labelled "delinquent".
Recent guidance from the Johannesburg High Court in Brondani
v Brondani (2021/52977) [2025] ZAGPJHC 1157 (17 November 2025)
directly tackles two main points of previous ambiguity in the
Protocol: paragraph 4.5.1, regarding the acceptance or opposition
to mediation in the initial Rule 41A notice, and paragraph 4.7,
which treats notices as irregular if they reject mediation without
'cogent reasons', a term that the Protocol does not define.
The judgment sheds some