It's rare to see equestrian metaphors in judgments from the
Labour Court, but in Samancor Chrome Ltd t/a Eastern Chrome
Mines v NUM obo NE Matshebele, the Labour Appeal Court saw it
fit to start its judgment with one:
"It has been said of some cases that the effort to
prosecute them is akin to flogging a dead horse. This case is not
of that kind; rather, this horse was stillborn."
The stillborn case involved an employee accused of using company
loyalty points without authorisation, which led to his dismissal.
At the arbitration, Samancor led only one witness, an assistant
manager at Pick 'n Pay, who explained how Smart Shopper points
work. In addition to this, Samancor also submitted a bundle of
documents, including a forensic report containing damning evidence
of the employee's guilt. However, none of these documents were
actually introduced into evidence by a witness, and the forensic
investigator was not called to testify regarding the report's
contents