1. Key takeaways
Provisional measures dismissed where the applicant fails to establish infringement on the balance of probabilities
The Court applied the “more likely than not” test for provisional measures. Since it found that on the balance of probabilities likely the patent is not infringed, the Application was dismissed on this ground alone, without needing to address the defendant’s defences on urgency or invalidity. The burden of presentation and proof lies with the applicant.
Claim construction decisive: “in a layer by layer manner” (Art. 69 EPC) was construed to mean each horizontal layer of a 3D printing purge tower must consist of a single material
The parties’ dispute centered on the feature “printing at least one purge tower in a layer by layer manner”. The Court interpreted this to require that each purge operation creates a new horizontal layer on top of the previous one, consisting of only one type of material (either part material or support material). The Court